This debate got very heated in the vbjirc chat [if you have java installed on your computer, click the button right next to your private message section].
Many questions were brought up and I'll do my best to list them so you can get a better understanding for the overall question posed.
With Saha out for the rest of the season, Welbeck is slotted in as United's 3rd choice striker.
Question 1: Do you think Welbeck is good enough to be United's 3rd choice striker? Why.
Frazier Campbell has been tearing it up with Hull in the Fizzy Pop Division during his loan stint, having netted 14 goals.
Question 2:
a. Is Frazier Campbell good enough to become United's 3rd choice striker?
b. Who do you think is rated higher with United's backroom staff. Welbeck or Campbell?
With United having signed Manucho for next season, provided his permit issues are behind him and the chance that Saha returns and both join the first team for next season. Do United...
Question 3:
a. Go out and get another striker? Who?
b. Keep either Campbell or Welbeck in the first team squad and dont' get another striker?
c. Loan both or one out? [indicate who]
With the top 4 and now those trying there hardest to get into this prestiage bracket in the epl buying up quality players,
Question 4: Can United afford to nuture either Campbell or Welbeck with the first team and not look to buy a striker?
And obviously the final question and the whole basis for this thread..
Quetion 5: Who is the better player for United's first team. Frazier Campbell or Danny Welbeck?